top of page

Large Hail

Atmospheric ingredients and forecast parameters/thresholds defining environments favorable for large hail

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram

Atmospheric Ingredients

Ingredients necessary for large hail : 

​

The primary ingredients necessary for the production of large hail are often also the ones necessary for the production of  "organized" convection. Those are : instability, moisture, lift and vertical wind shear. Since supercell storms are known to be prolific hail producers, identifying pre-convective environments that specifically favor supercell formation is usually very useful. This is often attributed to the fact that the presence of a mesocyclonic circulation within a thunderstorm cell increases updraft speeds via storm-scale pressure perturbations. Updraft speeds can sometimes increase by as much as a factor of 2.

​

Furthermore, the following specific atmospheric ingredients are known to favor large hail in severe convective storms including supercells :

​

  • High elevation : This limits the time hailstones have to melt before reaching the ground which increases the probability of receiving larger hail (the Jura and northern/southern Alpine foothills are notorious for large hail)

​

  • Low freezing levels : This limits the time hailstones have to melt before reaching the ground as well and also increases the vertical depth within the storm cloud where hailstone formation is possible.

​

  • Dry mid-level air : This favors evaporational cooling of environmental air into a thunderstorm and will result in a lower wet-bulb zero level, thereby also limiting the time hailstones have to melt before reaching the ground. This same dry entrainment can also favor strong downdraft-driven straight-line winds at the surface.

​

  • High CAPE : This is probably the most important factor in determining hail size. The higher the CAPE, the higher the upward vertical velocities inside the updraft which directly aids in suspending heavier/larger hailstones and accumulating ice layers on them within the thunderstorm. 

​

  • High vertical wind shear : Strong mid/upper-level winds tilt the updraft which allows a separation between the updraft and the downdraft. This in turn allows both the updraft and downdraft to strenghten and for CAPE to be maximized to its fullest potential since precipitation loading becomes less of a problem.

​

  • Low precipitable water (PW) : Since the weight of the precipitation will influence the strength of the updraft to some extent even in tilted storms, airmasses with higher moisture values will result in more precipitation loading. This will tend to reduce the CAPE since the force of gravity pushes down on the hydrometeors. Therefore low PW values when coupled with high CAPE can produce large hailstones. Low precipitation supercells are notorious for producing very large hail.

​

So to summarize :

  • Hailstone size is maximized by : high elevation, low freezing levels, low PW, dry mid-level air, high CAPE and large wind shear. Supercell thunderstorms usually thrive in these types of environments, especially low-precipitation supercells, since they thrive in low PW environments.

  • Hailstone size is minimized by : low elevation, high freezing levels, high PW, moist  mid-levels, low CAPE and weak wind shear. These environments favor weak maritime tropical airmass convection which is not conducive for hail.

​​

In a nowcasting environment, additional clues that can alert forecasters on the presence of large hail in on-going convection via radar, include :

 

  • Reflectivity values above 55 dBZ : generally agreed-upon reflectivity threshold for the outer periphery of thunderstorm hail cores

  • Vertically Integrated Liquid (VIL) Density values above 3.5 (severe threshold with dime/nickel (1.8 cm / 2.1 cm size), above 4.0 (1 inch or 2.5 cm hail) and above 4.3 (golfball 5 cm size)

  • The presence of hail spikes : reflectivity extensions behind thunderstorm reflectivity echoes in the shape of a spike in the down-radial direction of the radar. This signature is sometimes not visible in filtered radar data but always visible in raw data (Refl-U product in RadarLive PBS intranet).

  • The presence of lightning jumps : lightning jumps (especially intra-cloud)  have been shown to be often associated with increased hail production in thunderstorms and show some predictive value in terms of nowcasting imminent hail falls at the ground (0 to 45 minute leadtimes, Wapler 2017).

  • Probability of Hail (POH) and Maximum Expected Severe Hail Size (MESHS) radar algorithms : these are helpful but sometimes tend to overestimate hail probabilities and hail size diameters.

Forecast Parameters

Forecast ingredient parameters useful in determining whether pre-convective environments are favorable for large hail :

​

​

​

  • For High Instability :

    • CAPE [J/kg] :​

      • MLCAPE (Pivotal Weather - ICON)​

      • MUCAPE (Météociel - AROME) , MUCAPE (Pivotal Weather - GFS)

    • Lifted Index [°C] :

      • SBLI (Pivotal Weather - GFS)

      • MULI (WRF-NMM 2km)​

​​​​

​

​

  • For Supercell Thunderstorm Probability :

​

  • For Direct Hail Probability Estimation :

​​​​

Forecast Parameter Thresholds

Altitude & Freezing Levels

Altitude of concerned region

< 500 m : low-lying region less favorable for large hail​

500-800 m : slightly elevated region facilitating occurrence of large hail

800-1000 m : moderately elevated region more favorable for large hail

> 1000 m : elevated region quite favorable for large hail

Freezing Levels

< 2500 m : very low freezing level very favorable for large hail​

2500-3000 m : low freezing level favorable for large hail

3000-3500 m : intermediate freezing level less favorable for large hail

> 3500 m : high freezing level unfavorable for large hail

Moisture

Mixing Ratios (@ surface 2m)

< 3 g/kg : very dry

​3 - 5 g/kg : dry 

5-7 g/kg : slightly humid/moist

7-12 g/kg :  moderately humid/moist

12-15 g/kg : very humid/moist

> 15 g/kg : extremely humid/moist

Dew Points (@ surface 2m)

< -3 °C : very dry

​-3 to +5 °C : dry 

5 to 10 °C : slightly humid/moist

10 to 17 °C :  moderately humid/moist

17 to 20 °C : very humid/moist

> 20 °C : extremely humid/moist

Equivalent Potential Temperatures (850 hPa)

< 5 °C : very dry

​5 - 18 °C : dry 

18 - 30 °C : slightly humid/moist

30 - 45 °C :  moderately humid/moist

45 - 60 °C : very hot & humid (très lourd)

> 60 °C : extremely hot & humid (ext. lourd)

Cloud base heights (LCL/CCL)

< 1000 m : low cloud base​

1000-2000 m : intermediate cloud base

2000-3000 m : high cloud base

> 3000 m : very high cloud base

Downdraft CAPE (DCAPE)

< 600 J/kg : weak evaporational downdraft potential​

600 - 1000 J/kg : moderate evaporational downdraft potential

1000 - 1400 J/kg : strong evaporational downdraft potential

> 1400 J/kg : very strong evaporational downdraft potential

Relative Humidity (mid-levels)

<  40% : quite dry

​40-60% : somewhat dry 

60-80% : somewhat humid/moist

80% :  very humid/moist

Total Precipitable Water (TPW)

< 30 mm : low airmass water content very favorable for large hail​

30-40 mm : intermediate airmass water content favorable for large hail

40-50 mm : high airmass water content less favorable for large hail

> 50 mm : very high airmass water content unfavorable for large hail

Instability

MLCAPE/MUCAPE

​0 : stable

0-700 J/kg : weakly unstable

700-1500 J/kg :  moderately unstable

1500-3000 J/kg : very unstable

> 3000 J/kg : extremely unstable

Lifted Indices

>+2°C : stable

​+2 to 0 °C : stable/neutral

0 to -2 °C : weakly unstable

 -2 to -4 °C :  moderately unstable

-4 to -6 °C : very unstable

< -6 °C : extremely unstable

Temperature Lapse Rates (mid-levels)

​<  5.5 - 6.0 °C/km : stable

6.0 - 7.0 °C/km : slightly unstable/steep

7.0 - 8.0 °C/km  :  moderately unstable/steep

8.0 - 9.0 °C/km : very unstable/steep

> 9.0 °C/km : extremely unstable/steep

Vertical Wind Shear

0-6 km Bulk Shear

0 - 15 kts : weak shear (favors ordinary convection - airmass/pulse thunderstorms)

15 - 30 kts : moderate shear (favors multicellular convection - multicell clusters/squall lines)

30 - 45 kts : strong shear (favors organized convection - hybrid multicell/supercell structures, organized/strong squall lines)

> 45 kts : very strong shear (favors severe organized convection - isolated supercells, supercells embedded in squall ines, bow-echoes, line echo wave patterns (LEWP) along squall lines, derechoes)

0-3 km Bulk Shear

0 - 15 kts : weak shear (favors gust fronts clearly outrunning the convection)

15 - 25 kts : moderate shear (favors gust-fronts closer to the convection)

25 - 40 kts : strong shear (favors deep cold pools with strong gust fronts on leading edge of convection)

> 40 kts : very strong shear (favors very deep cold pools with very strong gust fronts on leading edge of convection - important for bow echoes)

Supercell Thunderstorm Probability

Supercell Composite Parameter (SCP)

< 0.5 : low values  (favors non-supercellular convection)

0.5 - 2.0 : moderate values (favors surface-based or elevated hybrid multicellular/supercellular convection)

2.0 - 6.0 : high values (favors a moderate risk of surface-based or elevated supercell thunderstorms)

> 6.0 : very high values (favors a high risk of surface-based supercell thunderstorms)

Supercell Detection Index (SDI) [ x10E-3 /s ]

< 1.0 : weak NWP-detected storm-scale rotation  (non or weakly-supercellular modeled convection)

1.0 - 3.0 : moderate NWP-detected storm-scale rotation (moderately intense modeled supercell mesocyclone)

3.0 - 10.0 : strong NWP-detected storm-scale rotation (intense modeled supercell mesocyclone)

> 10.0 : very strong NWP-detected storm-scale rotation (very intense modeled supercell mesocyclone)

Hail Probability

HailCast 

Check maximum hail size diameter forecast by the 1-d HailCast model via  ICON Convection favorite in NinJo

Total Column Graupel (TCG)

Check graupel field in model/product browser or in NinJo

Hail diameter > 2 cm when TCG > 10 mm

ESSL Automated Severe Weather Guidance (AR-CHaMo regression model)

Check generated map for probabilities of both 2 cm and 5 cm hail

Significant Hail Parameter (SHIP)

< 1 : Hail less than 4 cm in diameter expected

> 1 :  Hail greater than 5-6 cm in diameter expected

Contact

Je suis toujours à la recherche de nouvelles opportunités. Contactez-moi.

01 23 45 67 89

bottom of page